Alto Recorder
I currently have two alto recorders:
- Yamaha
302 plastic - a great practice instrument that can be used for
performance also
- Kung
Superio Plumwood - very nice instrument with sweet tone, great
intontation, and decent lower and upper registers. See here for details how I selected it.
392, anyone?
I'm not as excited about this prospect as I once was, but another
interesting thought is that an alto at A=392 (or "alto in
E-flat") could be used to play tenor/soprano saxophone lines (playing
with F fingerings) OR alto saxophone lines (playing with C fingerings.)
The only caveat is that the bottom two saxophones notes (notated Bb and
B) would not be available. Unfortunately, the only makers I've found
are rather pricey:
- Dolmetsch
Stanesby, Alto in E flat (440Hz) - £520.31 (pear/maple),
£550(satinwood/rosewood), £605(grenadilla/tulipwood),
£792.15 (kingwood/european boxwood) - just guessing, but probably
would like satinwood or tulipwood. BTW, xe.com
says £550=$1,033.50 and £605=$1,136.85 (on 5/24/2006.)
- Philippe Bolton,
Alto after Charles Bizey - 1144.00 €, xe.com says 1144€=$1,477.65
- Boudreau
Bizey Alto A:392 - $1600 (european boxwood)
- Tom Prescott,
Bressan - $1825
- Ralf Ehlert, Late
Baroque, Bressan, Alto in 392 - 1420€ = $1,834.15
- Peter
Van Der Poel - 1440€
- Adrian Brown -
1520€ = $1,934.47
- von Huene Scherer
- $2200
A well-respected authority on these instruments (e-mail me if you want
to know more) had this to say:
I tried a few Dolmetsch Stanesby altos
at A415 while I was in
Stockstadt at the recorder exhibition and I was not too impressed
overall with their somewhat anemic sound. I haven't tried any of their
instruments at A392 so I can't comment directly on them. So far I have
been most impressed by Ehlert Bressans at A392 and Adrian Brown Bizey's
at A392, closely followed by Peter Van Der Poel's Bizey at A392. The
used Bressan at A392 by David Ohanessian is a lovely instrument, but
the sound is probably a bit too delicate for playing jazz. The von
Huene Scherer alto at A392 is not bad at all, but perhaps a bit pricey
and not as lovely sounding as the first three I mentioned. At all
costs, avoid the Philip Bolton Bizey at A392 because 1) the tone
quality is a bit harsh, and 2) they are slightly sharp overall in
pitch.
If you want to play along with Bb or Eb jazz charts/recordings (e.g.
Aebersold, Hal Leonard, etc.,) a much cheaper option than stepping down
your recorder is to use a program like Transcribe ($50) or Audacity (free!) to
change the pitch of the recording up a step and use your standard 440
alto.